Book Review: The Dead Come to Stay by Brandy Schillace

Part of Paste Creative Book Tours

An amateur autistic sleuth. A wry English detective. A murder case that thrusts them both into the wealthy world of the rare artifacts trade.

Book Synopsis

Following the death of her mother, Jo Jones leaves the big city for the quiet hills of North Yorkshire after inheriting her family’s estate, Ardemore. She’s hoping for a fresh start, but until her freelance editing career takes off, she needs another source of income.

The property includes the manor (in desperate need of work), a smaller attached cottage (slightly more livable), and expansive gardens. Jo decides to renovate the cottage’s attic and rent it out for extra money.

While exploring the estate, Jo uncovers traces of ancestors she never knew existed—including a mysterious woman in a half-destroyed painting—and suspects her late Uncle Aiden’s belongings may hold answers to her family’s cryptic history.

Her quiet plans change when local detective James MacAdams discovers a body in the nearby woods—one with unexpected ties to Jo. The investigation draws them into the wealthiest corners of Yorkshire: luxury hotels, elite country clubs, and opulent estates.

But beneath the surface lies a darker truth: local teens, many of them refugees, are disappearing, and the case seems linked to a shady architectural firm—one that also employed the murder victim. This path leads Jo and MacAdams deep into the dangerous world of rare artifacts and antique trading.

Review

Brandy Schillace’s The Dead Come to Stay is a clever, atmospheric mystery that pairs an unlikely duo—Jo, a brilliant amateur sleuth, and MacAdams, a dry-witted detective—in a gripping tale of murder, rare artifacts, and buried secrets.

The narrative unfolds through dual points of view (Jo and MacAdams) and they intersect during the murder investigation. Jo is a refreshing protagonist: insightful, observant, and neurodivergent in ways that give her a unique investigative edge. Her dynamic with MacAdams—built on subtle humor, mutual respect, and occasional exasperation—adds warmth to the suspense. Schillace skillfully balances character development with a tightly woven plot, making it easy to invest in both the mystery and the partnership.

Jo’s exploration of her family’s past adds emotional depth, while the artifact-trading subplot offers moral complexity and high stakes. The tension in the murder investigation escalates with every revelation, and just when you think you’ve reached the solution, another twist emerges. With language that is easy to understand and follow, the action flows seamlessly through the pages until the satisfactory ending.

The Dead Come to Stay is as intellectually sharp as it is entertaining. Rich with themes of identity, family, friendship, and justice, it’s a compelling choice for fans of unconventional detectives and smart, layered storytelling. It is recommended for fans of cozy mystery novels such as those by Agatha Christie, Richard Osman (The Thursday Murder Club), and Joanne Fluke (Hannah Swensen series).

*Thank you to Stephanie Caruso from Paste Creative Book Tours for the gifted ARC. I have not been compensated for this review and all views and opinions expressed are my own.