Simplicity by Mattie Lubchansky: A Graphic Novel Review

From the acclaimed author of the horror sensation Boys Weekend, Mattie Lubchansky returns with Simplicity—a vibrant and biting new graphic novel. Set in a dystopian future, Simplicity follows a timid academic sent beyond the fortified walls of New York City to investigate a mysterious cult in the wilds of the Catskill Mountains. It will be released on July 29 and is available for pre-order. (Penguin Random House, 2025)

---

📚 Synopsis

In 1977, a group known as the Spiritual Association of Peers takes over an abandoned summer camp in the Catskills, founding a secluded community they call Simplicity.

Fast forward to 2081: scholar Lucius Pasternak, a trans man, lives in the authoritarian New York City Administrative and Security Territory, established after the U.S. dissolves in 2041. When billionaire real estate mogul and current mayor Dennis Van Wervel offers Lucius a job documenting Simplicity for a new museum, Lucius reluctantly agrees.

What begins as an anthropological assignment quickly evolves into something deeper. Lucius is captivated by the community’s strange rituals and by Amity Crown-Shy, a charismatic acolyte born and raised in Simplicity. But soon, terrifying visions—sensual and surreal—begin to haunt Lucius. When members of the cult start to vanish, leaving signs of violence behind, Lucius and Amity are forced to confront an otherworldly presence: a creature the community calls The Lamentation.

Together, they journey into the lawless Exurb Zones, home to prepper enclaves and reclusive elites, to uncover the truth—and face the real threat to Simplicity’s survival.

---

🖋️ Review

In this bold and satirical graphic novel, Lubchansky explores the themes of power, identity, and ideology. Set in a fragmented and fortified America, Simplicity questions what happens when utopian dreams meet dystopian realities.

Lubchansky’s artwork is electric—balancing cartoonish expressiveness with detailed, immersive environments. The contrast between Lucius’ internal repression and Amity’s easy confidence adds emotional depth, while the narrative dives into authoritarian control, cult psychology, and queer identity with nuance and intelligence.

What begins as a critique of surveillance culture and elitism becomes a layered, often unsettling story about the seduction of simple answers in a complex world. The horror elements—hallucinatory creatures and violent disappearances—are matched by dark humor and emotional insight. The language is clear and expressive: “Are my dreams seeping into the real world? They persist.”

This is a must-read for fans of graphic novels that blend science fiction, horror, and political commentary. Provocative, beautifully drawn, and deeply thought-provoking, Simplicity stands out as one of the year’s most original graphic novels.

⚠️ Note: Contains nudity and sexual content.

“There’s no such thing as leaving the world, is there? We’re in the world. The choice has already been made for us.”

*Thank you to Demetris Papadimitropoulos/Pantheon Books for the gifted ARC for review consideration. I have not been compensated for this review and all views and opinions expressed are my own.